News 
 Local News 
 News 
 General 
 Rain little help as lakes dammed 

Rain little help as lakes dammed

17 Jul, 2009 02:04 PM
This week’s heavy rain in the Currency Creek and Finniss River catchments is pouring into Lake Alexandrina, but water experts say it will make little impact on the health of the internationally famous lower lakes and Coorong.

Creek and river road crossings were closed for part of the week as water flooded fords.

But the government, which is already building a series of three dams which will divide Lake Alexandrina into separate, artificial salt and fresh-water zones, warned that no amount of local rain could make a realistic difference.

Environment department chief executive Allan Holmes said local rain could raise the water level marginally – both Lakes Alexandrina and Albert are now below sea level.

Only a huge inflow from the Murray-Darling catchment further upstream will see the lake’s health restored.

The building of the three so-called regulators, actually earthen and steel-paneled dams, is fiercely opposed by local environment groups.

The government hopes to stop acidic water from the Finnis River and Currency Creek flowing into the Goolwa Channel, but environmentalists say a much better solution would be to remediate the area by planting more native and imported grasses, which would increase soil nutrients.

Last weekend South Coast campaigners set up a “fresh water embassy” on the lake’s shores, mirroring the Aboriginal tent embassy at Parliament House in Canberra.

Three hundred and fifty people, including Greens senator Sarah-Hanson Young and her daughter and mother, joined “mourners” paying their respects to the Murray.

“We needed to grieve,” said Professor Diane Bell of the River, Lakes and Coorong Action Group. “Watching on a daily basis as thousands of tonnes of clay and sand and rumble are being dumped in the channel between Hindmarsh Island and Clayton Bay, hearing the whine of the trucks and knowing that this weir will cut Lake Alexandrina off from the fresh water of the Finniss River and Currency Creek has been painful. A complex eco-system is being cut into pieces and there are no credible plans to undo the damage.”

“This is ecological vandalism,” said Sarah Hanson-Young. Flags were lowered to half mast and the procession poured water from the tributaries into the narrow stretch of water still running between the cliff and the weir wall. A wreath of fresh water rushes and grasses in the shape of a boat was then cast into the water and sailed off to Lake Alexandrina.

“Our most recent monitoring shows that the water coming down the Finniss River and Currency Creek is not acidic,” said Prof Bell. “The rains have diluted the acids and the water at the weir site is alkaline. The country is greening up. A prudent policy of a responsible government would be to ensure that fresh water from the tributaries continues to flow and is not dammed and diverted further upstream.”

Adelaide University aquatic ecologist Dr Mike Geddes said the great earthen wall represented “the biggest environmental insult to the River Murray system.”

Dr Geddes said the danger of acidity had been exaggerated.

Meanwhile, a senior United Nations adviser on international water issues, Maude Barlow, wants a State of Emergency declared and a Royal Commission into the Murray and lower lakes.

Ms Barlow extensively toured the region recently and gave a damning assessment of state and federal water policies.

“I toured the Lower Lakes of the Murray-Darling Basin by land and air and was devastated by what I saw,” she said this week.

“Federal and State Governments kept blaming climate change and drought for the mess but there is much more to it than that. Australia has become wealthy by damming and diverting the the once mighty Murray-Darling Basin to grow crops for export and successive leaders have allowed the country's water heritage to be shipped out of the country in what is called virtual water trade.

“The river is so over over-extracted, particularly during drought, it is dying from the mouth up, and the resulting sulphuric acid and saline invasion is steadily advancing, killing the animals who ingest it.”

The call for a royal commission was rejected by water economist Mike Young, who said the lower lakes were now beyond help. A royal commission was needed 18 months ago, he said, and it is now too late.

Last month Professor Young told a parliamentary committee that parts of the Murray-Darling should be allowed to die to save other parts of the river system.

“It’s not about just closing off part of the lower lakes," he said. “It's about looking at every backwater, every wetland, every forest throughout the system from top to bottom and having a very careful discussion about which bits we invest in keeping going and which bits we are prepared to let go if it doesn't rain.”

The National Trust in SA has already placed the lower lakes and Coorong on its heritage-at-risk list.

“The Lower Lakes and Coorong is recognised as one of the top six water bird sites in Australia and is listed as a wetland of international significance under the Convention of Wetlands,” says the Trust.

“Existing regulatory structures and excessive water extraction have, for many years placed stress on the natural systems by changing the volume and pattern of seasonal flow of water.

“There has been an ongoing decline in biodiversity and population abundance for various species, including aquatic plants, migratory and sedentary birds, fish and frogs.

“The SA Government is taking three actions at present, none of which address the problem of lack of provision for environmental flows,” the National Trust says.

Meanwhile, the government has possibly already decided, but not yet announced, its position on the nationally-controversial Wellington Weir.

The project involves an artificial dam right across the Murray upstream of the lakes. It would completely stop the flow of Australia’s largest river system to the sea.

State Minister for Water Security Karlene Maywald says the decision will be reassessed at the end of August.

“Every month, the South Australian Government analyses seasonal forecasts and advice from the Murray-Darling Basin Authority to take into account the impacts on the Lower Lakes,” she said.

“Decisions such as the recent decision to cease pumping into Lake Albert also impact on whether we need to build the weir or not.

“A decision to commence construction will depend on local rainfall in SA and interstate over the coming months.”

According to Professor Young, while the government calls the Wellington dam ‘temporary’, it could well end up being a permanent barrier.

“Environmental impact statements assumed that this problem is going to be solved in three years' time because there'll be enough water in the system to enable us to remove the weir,” he said previously.

“I can't see how we can get the water back in the system in sufficient volumes that we could take out the weir.”

He says a flood similar to the monster 1956 event would be needed to fill the lakes and let the weir be demolished.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size
Page:
single page

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
Just typical of this Rann government, they dont listen to all the experts just their pet ones. Rann and his Ministers may well survive the next election only because the Liberals have stuffed up any hope. But rest assured we will remember Mike and Co !!!!!!!!!!!
Posted by kym, 17/07/2009 4:16:06 PM, on The Independent Weekly
The lack of action by the Rann government disgusts me. The mishandling of our precious water resources, with both the introduction of the desalination plant and lower lake weir, have turned a lifetime Labor voter against them. The blatant disregard for the beautiful and unique Murray-Darling river system in this country is abhorent, yet if anyone were to properly understand its significance you would think it would be the South Australians who have relied apon it so much in our history. Instead we are discarding and dismissing it like so much bad news. Positive action needs to be taken, water reclamation and flows secured from upstream to replenish this once mighty river. God help us because Rann certainly won't.
Posted by buckstopshere, 17/07/2009 9:53:55 PM, on The Independent Weekly
Hendrik, instead of just listening and taking information from the community as bonafide experts because they have the title of professor with no thought to assessing against the information out there publicly, perhaps you should look at the information on the EPA website that shows how low the pH of water in currency creek was a couple of weeks ago and probably still is and think about the fact that the water coming down the tribs doesn't dilute the acid it washes more in. Please also think about the fact that the weir or as you put it, dam at Wellington still does pass water and wont permanently cutoff the lower lakes - focus on getting the government to do something about water for the site now and in the future and making sure these structures are removed later - speaking of which, the clayton dam being made from sand means they can dredge it and remove it much more easily than if it is made from rock - perhaps they are listening to us when we engage sensibly?
Posted by Sebastian, 18/07/2009 9:05:33 AM, on The Independent Weekly
To Geddes, Bell, Hansen-Young etc. Underestimated the risk of acidity? What a joke. You people have been living with a regulated system for your whole lives. The system is never going to return to its former glory, it needs to be managed. Acidity is a huge risk that will only increase with time. First Currency, next Finniss and then the Lakes. Should we just let these systems turn to vinegar while we pray for water from upstream? This is what you all seem to be suggesting. The government will never do a thing right in your eyes. How about a dose of reality people. Perhaps some young voices are required to give you old fossils a wake up call. You guys seem to be so stuck in your ways praying for a return to the good old days that you are failing to see how dire the threat is to this region from Acid. The regulator looks to be coming along nicely. Will be great when it is finished.
Posted by IgnorantFools, 19/07/2009 5:40:05 PM, on The Independent Weekly
Hindsight is a beautifull science! Thanks to the government for doing something, taking a stand and after evaluating all the facts as best they can in the current environment without procrastinating and not going to sleep in multi-million-meetings to go forward with a plan that seems workable. I have not seen so much whining in my life, if government does nothing, they are labled wrong, if they do something, they are also labled wrong.
Posted by JEP, 20/07/2009 11:11:04 AM, on The Independent Weekly
Sebastion and Ignorant Fools, valadating your views based on the reports of the EPA is like letting the fox watch the hen house. Ignorant you are so quick to condem us who have seen what the inaction of Govts can do to our water supply, it is many of you so called young turks spinning smoke and mirrors for the pollies, the young pollies who have betrayed this State like Penny Wong the Queen of spin, I am not praying for a return to any older times, but i do know that not so along ago the Murray ran fairly well freely before Young Pollies sold us people down stream out. Pity you didnt fight for our water rights instead of taking the young way around it, the path of least resistance typical, we will see who the fools are in a couple of years Ignorant.
Posted by kym, 20/07/2009 11:39:12 AM, on The Independent Weekly
For all you suggesting the acid risk posed is not serious......look at the data. http://www.epa.sa.gov.au/lower_la kes.html At least you can be safe knowing the EPA are quite transparent and are not swayed by other departments or politics. They report the facts.....the question is do you understand science, water chemistry? Looking at your opinions....I think not.
Posted by IgnorantFools, 20/07/2009 10:02:20 PM, on The Independent Weekly
I cannot believe a solution that is so simple to implement is being ignored. Lake Albert has now been desecrated by the decision to barrier it from the river system and let a Ramsar recognised WETLAND become a barren DRYLAND. The international Ramsar Convention has been contacted and is in secret negotiation with the government on the requirement for a viable connection with the Coorong to be established via the Southern side. See http://www.lakesneedwater.org for real fact based information.
Posted by Save Lake Albert, 21/07/2009 10:45:03 AM, on The Independent Weekly

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
Related Coverage
MULTIMEDIA
17 July, 2009

Most popular articles

Indaily
1) Apple iPhone 4 32GB44 plans 12%
2) Apple iPhone 4 16GB44 plans 6%
3) HTC Desire4 plans 2%
4) Apple iPhone 3GS 8GB33 plans 2%
5) Sony Ericsson Xperia X10 Mini Pro37 plans 1%

Mobile Phones | Broadband Plans

Get the best deal at Fairfax Digital - Rural Press



The Independent Weekly







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Navigate

Classifieds

More Ways to Read

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2010. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...