Three prisoners jammed day and night in a cell designed for one is not pushing prisons to bursting point.
That’s the view of a trio of ministers, Treasurer Kevin Foley, Attorney-General Michael Atkinson, and jails minister Carmel Zollo.
“What we’re making very clear is that if we’ve got to rack ’em, pack ’em and stack ’em we will,” Mr Foley said on Wednesday.
Yet the Treasurer is condemned by his own words. Mr Foley attacked this very position 1994.
“We see flashpoint: we see officers injured, prisoners put at risk and people taken to hospital. Why? Because this government is stocking our prisons full of prisoners,” he said while in Opposition in August 1994. “That is an inexcusable position,” he said then.
“I know that it is politically popular to be tough on crime and to say, ‘Who gives a damn about prisoners?’ That strikes a pretty good political chord. But some of them are not murderers; some are not rapists.
“It is without parallel for us to rack ’em, pack ’em and stack ’em as we are currently doing in the Adelaide Remand Centre, Yatala and all our State’s prisons,” he piously lectured the Brown Liberal Government in ’94.
An Independent Weekly investigation showed last Friday that SA has the worst prison system in the country, a dismally failing rehabilitation program, the nation’s longest jail terms and the worst overcrowding in the country.
The government responded to that by announcing this week it would triple the number of people kept in one-person cells. The SA Treasurer said he wants to pack inmates because they don’t deserve better.
Community outrage followed Mr Foley’s turnaround yesterday.
Civil Liberties Council president George Mancini was appalled. “The government treats human beings worse than animals,” he said. “You really wouldn’t treat animals like that.”
Mr Foley said; “If some softies and civil libertarians get upset then tough luck.”
Mr Mancini said this ignored international treaties on the humane treatment. “Australia signed those treaties. You can’t treat people like this in the 21st century – there’s an obligation, a duty of care.”
Independent Weekly research last week revealed that more than half the people in SA jails had been in jail before, and this figure is changing because more people than ever before are being locked up.
Mr Foley boasted that the government’s law-and-order agenda was driving up prisoner numbers.
But the state has failed to match rising prison numbers with more jail cells. In SA people jailed for a traffic offence share cells with violent offenders. Young people are locked up with adults.
“The Rann Government failure to separate adult and juvenile offenders has breached a 42-year-old international treaty to protect human rights,” Opposition Corrections spokesman Stephen Wade said.
Prison officers are not allowed to speak publicly about atrocious conditions in jail. “If they do, they’ll be in breach of the Public Sector Management Act,” said Public Service Association chief industrial officer Peter Christopher. “They can be sacked for breaking the law.”
One prison officer who spoke to the Independent Weekly on the basis of anonymity said people were dehumanised.
“They are caged and treated like animals so we’ve taught them to behave that way in jail and when they’re finally released into the community.”
It was a very different Mr Foley in 1994. “We should actually be trying to rehabilitate
them; we should be trying to make them deliver a useful contribution to society. However, the government will never do it when it is racking, packing and stacking them in the prisons,” he said while trying to become Minister.
Facilities at the city watch-house are now so poor, says Mr Wade that there is only shower for up to 35 people.
A second, recently-retired prison officer with decades of experience said violence in jail was now a daily threat. “Almost all male prisoners – you could say 100 per cent – get raped at least once and some are repeatedly raped, sometimes gang-raped.
Mr Christopher said prisoners from rival gangs are often housed within the same prison, yet their separation was vital for security.
“We haven’t got the staff to supervise everybody,” said the second officer. “It’s not just them (the inmates) we’ve got to consider. Sometimes we’re so short-staffed we’re worried about our own protection.”
The opposition said yesterday that overcrowding was being soft on crime because increasing prison numbers showed the failure of the government’s approach.
“The community wants the government to stop crime before it happens, not just lock people up after the event,” Mr Wade said. “Would a victim prefer that the person who attacked them is put in prison or that they were not attacked in the first place?”
Mr Mancini said the government was acting as if no-one cared what happened to people once they were locked away and out of sight.
“People do care,” he said. “Their families care, the community cares. It’s just the government that doesn’t.”