News 
 Opinion 
 Editorial 
 General 
 Ask not for whom the bell polls 

Ask not for whom the bell polls

28 Mar, 2009 02:30 AM
Labor will win the next state election in March 2009 with the likely loss of only three seats, according to leading psephologist Malcolm Mackerras.

Mr Mackerras, who has an uncanny record of correctly predicting election outcomes far in advance of polling days, names the seats most likely to fall from Labor’s grasp as Norwood, Mawson and Light, held by Vini Ciccarello, Leon Bignell and Tony Piccolo respectively.

Labor currently holds a comfortable margin in the Lower House.

It has 28 seats, the Liberals 14, the National Party one and there are four independents.

Mr Mackerras believes the Liberal Party will fall well short of victory, and that even a minority government will be out of its reach.

But he predicts the Liberals will win two non-Labor seats in addition to picking up Norwood, Mawson and Light.

“I think Karlene Maywald, the National Party member in Chaffey, will lose to the Liberals,” he said.

Ms Maywald is in the unique position of being a conservative in a Labor Cabinet.

She was appointed to the Ministry by Premier Mike Rann after the 2002 State election, when Labor needed to shore up its numbers in a tight Parliament.

“The current member for Chaffey was elected a Nationals MP, but sold her soul to Labor,” Liberal Leader Martin Hamilton-Smith noted ruefully last November.

Federally the National Party is in coalition with the Liberal Party, and in Queensland the two parties have merged to form the Liberal National Party.

Ms Maywald is facing anger of an electorate which relies heavily on irrigation.

As Minister for the River Murray she is battling perceptions that she’s been ineffective in stopping other states grab what South Australians think is our share of the water resource.

Her decision to build the Wellington Dam and flood the Lower Lakes with salt water is unpopular with River Murray campaigners, but will have little effect on her vote in Chaffey.

There, irrigators are battling to keep their permanent plantations like oranges, almonds and cherries alive.

Maywald’s challenger is SA Murray Irrigators Association chair Tim Whetstone, who won Liberal pre-selection against Citrus Growers of SA president Mark Chown and businessman Brian Barnett.

The Liberals believe that Chaffey, which includes the towns of Renmark, Berri, Barmera, Loxton and Waikerie, will be, in Mr Hamilton-Smith’s words, “one of the keys to winning government”.

But it seems that somebody has changed the locks, at least on the river.

At the 2006 state election, Ms Maywald was returned with a primary vote of 53.2 per cent.

An ANPL poll of Chaffey voters in September last year revealed her support had collapsed to just 10 per cent, well behind the Liberals on 45 per cent and Labor on 17 per cent.

Mr Mackerras also predicts a Liberal win in Mt Gambier, currently held by independent Rory McEwen who also sat in the Labor Cabinet until this year’s reshuffle.

Mr McEwen is retiring at the next election, and the fight there will be a contest between the Liberal’s Steve Perryman and one of a number of high-profile independent candidates who’re expected to nominate.

The loss of both Chaffey and Mt Gambier, now held by the Labor-sympathetic independents, would give the Liberals two additional seats in the 47-member House.

But, says Mr Mackerras, this still would be far short of a conservative victory.

However Mr Mackerras is dismissive of the latest Advertiser poll conducted last week, which claimed a collapse of the Liberal vote in country SA and an easy win for the ALP in the 2010 election.

Mr Mackerras said the sample size, 522, was not large enough to make those predictions.

That poll showed 18 per cent of those questioned in metropolitan Adelaide believed Mr Rann was doing a good job as Premier, and 26 per cent thought he was doing a poor job.

This compares with 11 per cent and 25 per cent respectively for Mr Hamilton- Smith.

Mr Mackerras also predicts that the independent member for Mitchell, Kris Hanna, will have a tough job holding on to his seat.

He thinks Mitchell is likely to fall to Labor.

In Frome, Mr Mackerras believes that the newly-elected independent, Geoff Brock, will hang on despite an inevitably tough fight from the Liberal Party.

Brock won the recent by-election caused by the mid-term resignation of former Premier Rob Kerin.

Mr Mackerras blames Mr Kerin for the Liberal loss in Frome, saying Mr Kerin “behaved in a disgraceful way” by resigning.

“The Liberal Party traditionally gives life membership to former leaders,” Mr Mackerras said.

“In this case it should withhold that honour."

The Liberals are still talking confidently about their expected result in the state election.

Mr Hamilton-Smith also dismissed the recent poll on the basis of its sample size.

“The poll reckons Labor leads 57 to 42 (per cent) in the country, but in September they reckoned it was the Liberals 58 to Labor’s 42.

There’s no way you get those sort of wild swings,” said a spokesman for the Opposition leader.

The earlier poll also had a very small sample size – just 365 in total – which means the results and any interpretation of those results is almost meaningless.

But the Liberals are publicly saying that they can also win the seats of Morialta, Hartley, Newland, Frome, Adelaide and Bright, as well as those selected by Mr Mackerras.

There is some speculation that Mr Rann may abandon his current seat of Ramsay, based in Adelaide’s northwest.

The solidly Labor electorate is a long way from the Premier’s domicile; his address is in the affluent inner east.

Some observers suggest that Mr Rann might run in Norwood, where he lives.

Whether sitting member Vini Ciccarello supports this tactic is uncertain, but if it does happen then Mr Rann would end up representing the same electorate held by his former boss, Don Dunstan.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size
Page:
2

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
Does anyone care what Malcolm Mackerras thinks about anything? This guy has been wrong so many times about so many things and should have been put out to pasture years ago. It also irks me when someone who claims to be a psephologist wants to share his thoughts on non-psephological issues such as whether Kerin did the right thing by his party. Perhaps if Mr Mackerras put more time into psephological considerations, his prognostications might have something resembling the accuracy of guys like William Bowe (a.k.a. 'The Poll Bludger'), Adam Carr and Antony Green
Posted by Chris Keane, 15/04/2009 12:49:57 PM

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.

Most popular articles

Indaily
1) Apple iPhone 4 32GB44 plans 12%
2) Apple iPhone 4 16GB44 plans 6%
3) HTC Desire4 plans 2%
4) Apple iPhone 3GS 8GB33 plans 2%
5) Sony Ericsson Xperia X10 Mini Pro37 plans 1%

Mobile Phones | Broadband Plans

Get the best deal at Fairfax Digital - Rural Press



The Independent Weekly







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Navigate

Classifieds

More Ways to Read

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2010. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...